Modern web development is fast, scalable, and iterative. With new tools like ESBuild, SWC, and Sucrase emerging, we at Expo figured it was time to start looking at how we can utilize new bundler techniques to improve cross-platform app development.
Today I'm proud to introduce the largest bundling improvement, possibly in the history of React Native. This is the next large step in closing the gap between the native and web ecosystems.
To use it, update to expo-cli@^4.12.0 or greater, and enable the beta flag EXPO_USE_EXOTIC:
𝝠 EXPO_USE_EXOTIC=1 expo start
The results are as follows (measured against a hello world app):
expo start -c in a blank project (iOS) with Exotic enabled: ~100% faster.
To understand how these improvements work, you'll first need to understand how bundling works.
Consider every file and how long they take to Transpile
The files in our app can be divided into two logical groups; application code, and Node modules. This distinction is important for a bundler. Application code is unpredictable, the user can change the rules at any time. One day, you might use require in your code, and the next, you could be using import/export.
These files can be split into two different groups
The most obvious optimization would be to simply skip transforming our code. However, If we did this, many files would have runtime errors because they may be using language features that aren't supported in our runtime. For example, if you ship import/export syntax to a Node runtime, Node will error out because it doesn't know how to handle that feature.
Skipping all transformation would cause errors in many files
💡 React Native's Babel preset includes a long list of Babel plugins and does much of the same work as@babel/preset-env
Babel can transform our code, but it's very expensive
By default, Metro bundler will transform every file in your project using Babel. Using the most expensive transformation on the maximum amount of code is a simple approach that trades off speed for compatibility, but it turns out that we might not need to make this sacrifice for these two reasons:
Many Node modules, like react ship with CommonJS support, meaning the library author already transformed it, so you don't have to.
As your project progresses, you may find yourself adding Babel plugins for aliasing, adding dotenv support, etc. your untransformed Node modules almost certainly don't need these extra customizations, often they just need basic operations like import/export transformation, resulting in a lot of wasted time.
Metro transforms everything with Babel (even files that don't need to be transformed)
This is where my recent improvements come into place.
First, we group up the Node modules that are shipped untransformed, and skip transforming every remaining Node module, this is packages like react or lodash which go from some variable amount of time to transform, down to no time at all!
Already, this will result in some decent savings, but we can do more. In the React Native ecosystem, many packages are shipped untransformed (more on this later), meaning that the majority of our code is still being transformed with Babel.
As mentioned earlier, Babel has many customizations that you add for your project, and these customizations aren't needed for untransformed Node modules. If you take a look at this breakdown, you'll see that Babel is substantially slower than many newer options. There are plenty of reasons why these alternatives are faster, but the most important is that they trade off customizability for speed.
Switching all transformation over to one of these tools would be far from ideal because users would lose out on the ability to add custom language features to their projects. But there is one place we can safely use them…
In Expo CLI, we configure Metro to transpile our untransformed Node modules with Sucrase, resulting in substantially faster React Native bundling! We currently use Sucrase because:
According to the benchmarks, Sucrase is a very fast transformer, and we only need improved transformation. Notice: ESBuild is also a bundler and minifier, it's a bit of an apples to oranges comparison.
It has Flow support built-in, React Native ships with Flow types in place (I'd love to see this change!) so it's a no-op. I also experimented with using a fork of React Native that is transpiled ahead of time, but it was a bit inconvenient to maintain.
Finally, and possibly the most surprising: Sucrase is written in JS, whereas the others are native (Rust, Go, etc), this means that npm installs go smoother on Windows and Linux machines and reduces npm install log-spam from optional dependencies. This is a real concern for many new developers and it's also a tax on maintainers to handle issues related to the install logs.
We use a faster system for transforming static libraries; Surcase instead of Babel.
Metro bundler has no concept of “loader rules”, this is a feature from the popular bundler Webpack, that I've shoehorned into Metro with a custom transformer.
To summarize: “Exotic” is a Metro transformer with three default “loader rules”:
Application code uses Babel for max customization.
We compensate for untransformed Node modules by using Sucrase (or a related tool).
And finally, we pass everything else through to the runtime, without needing to transform it.
Exotic is a metro transformer with loader rules that handle groups of files differently.
And just like that, we now have a system which is a lot more like web development, and in some regards a little bit better. In the web ecosystem, there are so few (major) packages that need to be transformed locally that the concept of having first-class support for optimizing this step isn't really worth the effort or added complexity.
The React Native ecosystem is almost exclusively made up of packages which need to be transformed locally, providing us with ample reason to improve it with a Sucrase loader rule.
Again, the results are about 2x faster in basic “Hello World” projects and stay fast at scale, making your large production apps bundle noticeably faster than before:
As a bonus, bundle sizes are also smaller by about 18% in “Hello World” apps. This is because many libraries are already shipped in an optimal format, and by needlessly transforming them with a random Babel cocktail, we increase the size, but only a little bit, and everywhere.
With Expo's Exotic transformer we don't have this issue, we do less, and get more (technically we get less JS, but you get it)!
Running expo export in a fresh project with Exotic enabled: ~18% size reduction.
This approach isn't without its flaws. To quickly deduce which Node modules are untransformed, we need to keep a hard-coded list of the packages that don't work — it's not 100% comprehensive, packages that don't start with react-native-* or expo-*, etc, may need to be added manually.
Meaning you, as the user, have to know a little bit about what's going on behind the scenes — which is why I spent hours making animated gifs (harder than actually building the system).
This constraint is the same in the web ecosystem, where the user is responsible for manually defining every package that needs to be transpiled locally, e.g. in Next.js, this is done via next-transpile-modules. This is easier for web dev because most popular web packages take the time to ship modules as transformed code.
React Native is a little different. Because Metro bundler has been using this naive “transform everything” approach for so long, almost every community package (including react-native itself!) have been shipped as untransformed code.
In fact, Metro has first-class support for this anti-pattern. You could use a react-native field in your Node module's package.json to define where your source is (often this is TypeScript or Flow), and Metro will use that as the entry point instead of the main/module fields.
In Expo's Metro config, we compensated for these issues by making the following changes:
Expo's Metro config ships a hardcoded list of matchers for identifying packages like react-native which need to be transpiled locally, hopefully library authors read this article, update their packages, and we can reduce the hardcoded list to be nothing at all. In the future, just like web dev, each project should be responsible for maintaining a list of packages that require local transpilation.
I Need Your Help
This project is aimed at shifting the React Native ecosystem to ship better libraries and making Metro bundler work more like a web bundler. By closing this gap, and making React Native more bundler agnostic (like React.js) we can easily move between different bundlers like Webpack or ESBuild. No longer should we have to feel FOMO when React.js frameworks get lightning-fast bundler improvements, or useful new bundler plugins, etc. As React developers, we should be able to utilize these things too, but it'll take some major changes to catch up and make this a reality.
If you enjoyed this article and found it helpful, please share it with other React developers!
Special thanks to Lydia Hallie, and Brent Vatne for proofreading, Satyajit Sahoo for sanity checks on Metro bundler's react-native package.json feature, and as always the Expo team for sponsoring my research and open source.